How to Choose the Best Vegetarian Yogurt: A Buyer’s Guide
May 17, 2024

Welcome to Your Guide to Selecting the Perfect Vegetarian Yogurt
Whether you're a committed vegetarian or simply exploring healthier dairy and plant-based alternatives, choosing the right yogurt can enhance your diet significantly. This article is designed to help you navigate the diverse world of yogurts that align with vegetarian dietary preferences, focusing on those that also cater to various health considerations such as digestive health and allergen concerns.
Yogurts come in several types, each offering unique benefits:
- Traditional Flavored Yogurt: These are perfect for those who enjoy classic tastes with a twist of flavor.
- Plant-Based Yogurt: Ideal for vegans and those avoiding dairy, these yogurts use alternatives like coconut or almond milk.
- Yogurt Drinks: For a quick, drinkable snack that still packs the nutritional benefits of yogurt, these are a convenient choice.
- Kefir: A fermented drink that's rich in probiotics, kefir is great for digestive health.
- Yogurt Starter Cultures: For those interested in making their yogurt at home, starter cultures are essential.
To choose the right yogurt, consider the following criteria:
- Nutritional content, especially probiotic richness for digestive health (see options).
- Specific dietary restrictions like gluten-free or non-GMO (explore these yogurts).
Jump Ahead To Sections
1. Exploring Different Types of Yogurts
2. Nutritionally Enhanced Yogurts
3. Diet-Specific Yogurts
Exploring Different Types of Yogurts
This selection explores various yogurt types, from traditional flavored to innovative plant-based options, catering to vegetarians with additional dietary preferences or restrictions. These choices range from kid-friendly formulations to those designed for digestive health benefits.
![]() Once Upon a Farm Organic Apple & Cinnamon Overnight Oats, 4.0 Oz |
![]() Cultures for Health Greek Yogurt Starter Culture, 2 Packets |
![]() Redwood Hill Farm Goat Milk Yogurt, Plain, 32 Ounce (Pack of 6) |
![]() Siggis Strained Non-Fat Yogurt, Peach, 12 Pack |
Kids & Baby Yogurts |
Traditional Flavored Yogurt |
Yogurt |
Plant-Based Yogurt |
Nutritional Balance: The product provides a well-rounded nutritional profile, including essential vitamins and minerals, making it a balanced choice for children. Digestive Health: The high fiber content aids in digestion and supports gut health. Brand Reputation: The brand is recognized for its commitment to quality and ethical sourcing, enhancing its credibility. Texture: The creamy texture of the oats provides a pleasant eating experience. |
Nutritional Balance: The product is rich in probiotics and contains Vitamin B12, but lacks detailed nutritional information for a comprehensive evaluation. Digestive Health: Being a probiotic-rich product, it is likely to support digestive health, though specific fiber content is not provided. Flavor Complexity: The product is known for its traditional Greek yogurt taste, which is described as creamy and tart, offering a moderate level of flavor complexity. Texture: Described as having a creamy texture, which is a desired attribute for Greek yogurt. |
Brand Reputation: Rated high as Redwood Hill Farm is a known brand in the dairy industry, and the product is well-received. Flavor Complexity: Rated low as it is a plain yogurt with no added flavors. Texture: Rated high as it is described as having a delicate, smooth, and velvety texture. |
Nutritional Balance: Being low-fat and based on simple ingredients, it offers a moderately balanced nutritional profile. Brand Reputation: siggi's is recognized, but not among the top brands, leading to a medium rating. Flavor Complexity: The yogurt is described with a single flavor (Peach), indicating low complexity. |
Nutritionally Enhanced Yogurts
Focusing on yogurts known for their enhanced nutritional profiles, such as being rich in probiotics or low in fat. These yogurts are perfect for health-conscious individuals looking to incorporate beneficial bacteria into their diets without compromising on taste.
![]() Cultures for Health Greek Yogurt Starter Culture, 2 Packets |
![]() Beech-Nut Breakfast Toddler Food, Yogurt Banana & Berry, 3.5 oz |
![]() 365 by Whole Foods Market, Vanilla Low Fat Yogurt, 32 Ounce |
![]() Stonyfield Organic Kids Yogurt Cups Variety Pack, 6 Ct |
Probiotic-rich Vitamin B12 |
Low Sodium Sugar-rich Low Protein |
Low Fat Low Sodium Protein-rich |
Low Fat Low Sugar Organic |
Nutritional Balance: The product is rich in probiotics and contains Vitamin B12, but lacks detailed nutritional information for a comprehensive evaluation. Digestive Health: Being a probiotic-rich product, it is likely to support digestive health, though specific fiber content is not provided. Texture: Described as having a creamy texture, which is a desired attribute for Greek yogurt. |
Nutritional Balance: The product is low in protein and high in sugars, which may not provide the best nutritional balance for toddlers. Heart Healthiness: Low in cholesterol and saturated fat, making it heart-healthy for toddlers. Digestive Health: Contains 1g of dietary fiber, supporting digestive health but could benefit from higher fiber content. Flavor Balance: The balance of flavors is generally good, though the sweetness from sugars might be too high for some preferences. Texture: The creamy texture is well-received and suitable for toddlers. |
Nutritional Balance: The product offers a moderate balance of nutrients, but the high sugar content and lack of fiber are areas for improvement. Heart Healthiness: Low in fat and cholesterol, but the high sugar content may be a concern for heart health. Digestive Health: Lacks dietary fiber, which is essential for good digestive health. |
Nutritional Balance: The product offers a good balance of nutrients but is slightly lower in protein and fiber. Heart Healthiness: Low in cholesterol and saturated fat, which is beneficial for heart health. Digestive Health: Lacks dietary fiber, which is important for digestive health. Flavor Balance: The balance between sweetness and the natural yogurt flavor is well-maintained. Texture: The creamy and smooth texture is highly appreciated, offering a satisfying eating experience. |
Diet-Specific Yogurts
This group includes yogurts tailored to meet specific dietary restrictions beyond vegetarianism, such as gluten-free and non-GMO options. Ideal for consumers with sensitive diets, ensuring they don't have to compromise on flavor or health benefits.
![]() Yogurt Starter Cultures, Pack of 3 |
![]() Gerber Baby Food Pouches, Value Pack, 9 Count |
![]() Yogurt Starter Cultures - Pack of 5 Sachets |
![]() Beech-Nut Breakfast Toddler Food, Yogurt Banana & Berry, 3.5 oz |
Gluten-free Non-GMO |
GMO Free |
Gluten-free GMO-free |
Nut-free No Artificial Additives |
Allergen Free: Rated low as the product contains traces of lactose, which might be problematic for individuals with lactose intolerance. Digestive Health: Rated high as the product contains live active bacteria known for their positive impact on gut health. Brand Reputation: Rated high based on the product's popularity and positive user reviews, indicating a strong brand reputation. Flavor Complexity: Rated low as the product is specifically designed for making plain, mild yogurt, offering minimal flavor complexity. |
Brand Reputation: Gerber is a well-known and trusted brand in the baby and toddler food market, with a strong reputation for quality and safety. Flavor Complexity: The variety of flavors is appreciated, but the complexity is limited due to the straightforward nature of the product (pureed fruit and yogurt). |
Brand Reputation: Natural Probiotic Selection has a strong brand reputation, supported by the product's high user ratings and specific bacterial strains for authentic Bulgarian yogurt. Flavor Complexity: The use of specific live active bacteria like Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. Bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus suggests a moderate complexity in flavor, typical of traditional Bulgarian yogurt. Texture: The product is expected to have a moderately smooth and tart texture, typical of Bulgarian yogurt, based on user descriptions. |
Allergen Free: Contains milk, which is a common allergen, so it is not allergen-free. Digestive Health: Contains 1g of dietary fiber, supporting digestive health but could benefit from higher fiber content. Flavor Complexity: The flavor profile is simple, primarily banana and mixed berry, lacking complexity. Texture: The creamy texture is well-received and suitable for toddlers. |
About Soov
Soov helps consumers discover products and make informed shopping decisions. We use AI to create unbiased & meticulous product reviews, assortments and how-to guides. Our content is powered by information from product pages, buyer feedback and in-house analyst inputs.